A stroll down the aisles of any muskie-minded tackle shop worth its salt stirs the senses with a legion of lures built for the king of the Esox clan. Yet within this selection, one of the supple muskie softbaits reigns supreme for upping your odds of successâ€”Muskie Innovationsâ€™ Bull Dawg.
Basically a soft-plastic body balanced on a stout jig-head, the Dawg may be short on shine, and unassuming compared to cranks, jerkbaits, or hair. But in the hearts of modern muskie hounds, itâ€™s second to none for producing giant fish throughout much of the seasonâ€”especially for those anglers who know the nuances of making these baits perform.
â€śItâ€™s my number-one casting bait by far,â€ť says veteran big-water guide Bret Alexander. On Lake Michiganâ€™s Green Bay and Sturgeon Bay, Alexander connects clients to mammoth muskies topping the 50-inch mark each season, some pushing past 55 with obese bellies swelling beyond 30 inches.
â€śJune, July, and August are peak Bull Dawg months,â€ť he says. â€śI canâ€™t give you a scientific reason; thatâ€™s just when they produce the most muskies.â€ť This time-frame coincides with Alexanderâ€™s focus on forage-rich near-shore vegetation, â€śespecially the deep edges of weedbeds,â€ť he adds. â€śThe ideal scenario is where a healthy patch of submergent vegetation such as cabbage or coontail runs along a slowly tapering bottom from 5 to 7 feet of water out to 12 to 15 feet. In a perfect world, the grass should top out about a foot below the surface.â€ť
With his boat positioned over deeper water, Alexander moves parallel to the weededge, lobbing long casts inshore at a 45-degree angle to the bank. â€śThe bait should land in about 5 feet of water, and cut a slightly crosswise arc across the bed as it moves toward the deep edge,â€ť he says.
Although not as animated as some muskie baits, a Bull Dawg can be taught a few tricks. â€śExperimentation is key,â€ť says Alexander. â€śI sometimes start burning the bait back as soon as it lands. At other times, itâ€™s better to let it fall a foot or two, then begin reeling.â€ť
Retrieves vary as well. Slow and mostly steady, fast and jerky, combinations of each, all of the aboveâ€”and everything in betweenâ€”have their place in Alexanderâ€™s playlist. â€śSometimes I fish it like a jerkbait, other times I make slight adjustments by reeling faster or slower,â€ť he says. â€śMuskies rarely favor a static retrieve.
â€śOne of the biggest tricks to working a Bull Dawg is switching rod tip angles,â€ť he adds. â€śI often start a retrieve with the tip pointed downward in front of me, then shift it to my right, then left. These motions impart directional changes to the bait and trigger strikes. When youâ€™re using the switch-up approach, 90 percent of your hits come when you change rod angles.â€ť
Alexander also advises to never hit a potential sweet spot only once. â€śWhile itâ€™s not productive to beat a spot to death, you should always make a couple of casts over a prime area, working the bait at different depths, with different retrieves,â€ť he says. â€śTry the first one with the lure running high and steady, then make another deeper, for a high-low approach.â€ť If these casts fail to hookup, Alexander moves on. â€śKeep moving and keep trying,â€ť he encourages. â€śYouâ€™re looking for active fish, so donâ€™t stay in one place too long.â€ť
The nuts and bolts of Alexanderâ€™s presentation are straightforward: stout rod, 80- to 100-pound Berkley FireLine mainline, 60- to 80-pound fluorocarbon leader. Bait selection, which hinges on conditions, is another matter. â€śDark days call for dark baits, and sunny days mean bright baits,â€ť he says. â€śI know that flies in the face of some folksâ€™ conventional wisdom, but thatâ€™s how we roll.â€ť Itâ€™s worth noting that the Great Lakes muskie meccas Alexander favors are gin clear, with visibilities in the 20-foot range.
Another muskie sage who sings the praises of a well-placed Bull Dawg is known more for his exploits in the panfish and walleye arenas. Minnesota Northwoods guide and In-Fisherman Contributor Brian â€śBroâ€ť Brosdahl puts clients on pansies and â€™eyes year-round, but his heart is never far from the adrenaline rush of having a big muskie explode on his bait at boatside. â€śI used to guide for muskies and fish for them on my own before and after guide trips. But constantly restocking my boat with gear for different species got old, so I narrowed my guiding focus somewhat,â€ť he explains.
But once bitten, always a muskie fanatic. For Brosdahl, that means a lifelong affinity for Dawg shows. â€śA lot of the muskies on the lakes I fishâ€”Leech, Cass, Winnie, Plantagenetâ€”are recycled, meaning theyâ€™ve been caught before,â€ť he says. â€śThat translates into a lot of follows from cautious fish. But slow-moving chunks of soft plastic like Bull Dawgs are less alarming to gun-shy muskies, so they produce more strikes.â€ť
Such softbaits also shine for mimicking preferred forage species, Bro contends. â€śThese pulsating, soft-plastic blobs are dead ringers for soft-rayed baitfish like suckers, ciscoes, whitefish, shiners, and bullheads,â€ť he says. Yes, bullheads. â€śGet over the spines,â€ť he chides. â€śWhen a big, toothy predator crushes a bullhead and swallows it head-first, the spines are non-factors.â€ť Indeed, in more southern muskie lakes, bullheads are common food items in the fertile weedbeds giant muskies prowl.
While Alexander and many other experts employ erratic retrieves, Bro believes a subtle approach can be equally rewarding. â€śI like a non-jerky movement because thereâ€™s something about a big, soft-plastic bait slipping seamlessly through the water that trips jaded muskiesâ€™ triggers,â€ť he says.
Especially in heavy weedbeds, the constant gyrations are a muskie magnet, he notes. â€śSome people like to jerk and glide their softbaits, but I like to pull them along slowly. The thumping, paddling locomotions get muskiesâ€™ attention. Even when the bait is hidden from view by weedgrowth, its vibrations alert predators to its presence.â€ť
Of course there are other tricks in this Dawgâ€™s repertoire. The addition of a Bull Dozer or other similar in-line spinner blade at the nose adds thump and flashâ€”a boon in stained water and at night. And the mid-body blade of a HELI Dawg offers a unique look and feel, which works well on a straight retrieve or when helicoptered (hence the name) into weed pockets.
Indeed, a Dawg-style softbaitâ€™s appeal and uses are limited only by imagination. Not to knock flashier presentations, but this unassuming mass of jelly-like polymers is hard to beat for much of the Summer Period, when the fish of our dreams are oh, so close, but often Âfrustratingly elusive.
Dan Johnson of Harris, Minnesota, is director of the Cabelaâ€™s Masters Walleye Circuit, masterswalleyecircuit.com. Contact: Guides Bret Alexander, alexandersportfishing.com; and Brian Brosdahl, brosguideservice.com.