Is there a blue lure renaissance in the offing? An update

Yesterday we posted a blog about how Caitlin Young’s   science project has spawned a renewed interest in blue baits  among some anglers.

It was noted that several practitioners of Midwest finesse tactics have joined this contagion. These finesse anglers  want to see if Young’s conclusions about the effectiveness of blue baits for alluring channel catfish apply to black bass.

Thus from Groundhog Day until New Year’s Eve,  these anglers will use a variety of blue finesse  baits as they pursue largemouth, smallmouth and spotted bass that inhabit some of the small flatland reservoirs that grace northeastern Kansas.

I am part of this group of blue-finesse-bait testers. Yesterday, I was afloat from 10:15 a.m to 2:45 p.m.,  working with several combinations of blue baits at a 195-acre flatland reservoir in northeastern Kansas.  It was an auspicious start.

For about 40 minutes of this outing, I worked with an underwater camera, searching patches of emerging curly-leaf pondweed and other types of aquatic vegetation. So, I fished for about three hours and 50 minutes.

About 52% of the casts and retrieves were made with  five baits that exhibited various hues of blue. Four of them were soft-plastic baits affixed to a blue 1/16-ounce Gopher Tackle Original Mushroom Jig Head.  One bait was a blue-gray-and-chrome jerkbait.

For 48% of the time,  I used three lures that weren’t blue.  Two of those were green-pumpkin soft-plastic baits affixed to a chartreuse 1/16-ounce Gopher jig, and one was a watermelon-red-flake soft-plastic bait on a red 1/32-ounce Gopher jig.

By the time I made my last cast and retrieve at 2:45 p.m., I had landed 51 largemouth bass and one channel catfish. I failed to land eight largemouth bass. I garnered 14 strikes that didn’t hook a fish.

Most of the fish were small, but one largemouth bass weighed four pounds, nine ounces. That lunker was allured by a green-pumpkin Z-Man Finesse ShadZ on a 1/16-ounce chartreuse Gopher jig, and that bait also inveigled the channel catfish.

Thirty-three of the bass were caught on blue baits, and 28 of those 33  bass were caught on a purple-haze 2 1/2″ Z-Man ZinkerZ affixed to a blue 1/16-ounce Gopher.  That same ZinkerZ  also accounted for 15 of the 22 missed strikes and lost bass that I encountered. The ZinkerZ and jig that caught those 28 bass is featured in the photograph below.

The jerkbait failed to elicit a strike.

The surface temperature ranged from 40 degrees to 42 degrees. All of the bass and channel catfish were inhabiting a  mud flat in the back of a cove. This flat was bespangled with patches of emerging curly-leaf pondweed.  For about an hour, a significant number of gizzard shad dimpled the surface of this mud flat. All of the bass, as well as the channel catfish,  were caught in four to five feet of water.

 

This photograph shows that there are a considerable amount of blue hues embellishing this ZinkerZ. It's affixed to a blue 1/16-ounce Gopher Tackle Mushroom Jig Head.

Related posts:

  1. Is there a blue lure renaissance in the offing?
  2. The Virtues of the Kinky Worm and Other Cock-eyed Finesse Presentations
  3. ZinkerZ and Zero
  4. Finesse News Network: an update on lures
  5. Blue Cats—Where to Look for a 150

11 Responses

  1. Ned Kehde

    Brian Waldman of Coatesville, Indiana, sent me an e-mail that contain the following suggestion:
    "An interesting test would have been to fish the exact same
    ZinkerZ body size/color on two different color jig heads, one blue, one
    either red or chartreuse. My personal thought is that head color wouldn't
    make that much difference, and that since body color would be much more
    visible overall, that might be the more important key."
    I replied that we would do a jig head test, too.
    We are eager to get more suggestions from readers.
    Ned

  2. - Josh

    Ned,

    Awhile back I had mentioned that I would like to divulge a few finesse tactics that have served my extremely well, but hinderances prevented me from embracing this inclination until now. Once i’d read your thoughts on blue baits, it seems past due. You’ll see why below.

    Here I offer one of the more closely guarded components of my finesse repertoire…

    For several seasons now, cut-down stick-baits, primarily Z-man / Strike King variants, have been a major facet of my finesse approach. One poignant divergence from the a-typical midwest-finesse archetype that has really upsized the average weight of fish caught has been the use of skirted micro-jigs in tandem w/ larger trailers.

    The jig I use us the Owner Wacky Jig (1/32 – 1/8) w/ added keeper-barb (via heat-shrink tubing or piece of bent wire wrapped to shank w/ thread). The jigs are furnished w/ a hand-tied thin, fine silicone skirt trimmed to about 1" long. I believe that it is paramount to use at least three colors in the skirt, or, in extremely clear water, transparent tones to simply help guise the image / profile of the trailer. The Jigs are painted either blue or red. Depending on the density of cover, I will occasionally leave the double-bristle weed-guard intact. Normally this is removed, though.

    As for the trailer, I prefer 3" to 3.5" portions of the aforementioned 5" stick-baits.

    When a slowed rate-of-fall is preferred, I will apply a gel coating. It is a mixture of dry-fly gel-floatant and Megastrike gel-scent. I have had DEFINITIVE experiences wherein scent was a major factor, so it is always added to the floatant.

    The major exception to the color preferences mentioned above is possibly one of my favorites for kicker fish. The skirt is a compilation of transparent blue-glimmer and dark sapphire-blue strands, evenly distributed. The trailer is a 3.5" portion of or an entire 4" Senko in the smoke-pearl-blue color. I use a chartreuse head for this jig-pattern. This is a truly special color compilation for me, as it has caught a huge array of robust smallnouth and largemouth, including a 13.2 lb. beast. Unfortunately it was during the practice period…

    Although the gear-snob in me adores and routinely uses a roster of Megabass, GLX and St. Croix models for my midwest-finesse endeavors, I’ve found a more modestly priced option that you might consider trying, given your affinity for intelligent budgeting.

    Okuma makes a 7’ ML spinning rod, 2-piece, in their SST line-up that is really incredible for the money. I’d initially purchased this stick for my father, and whilst showing him how to utilize his new tool, I was really impressed. It can be had for under $40, has Zirconium inserts, which i’ve noticed really bequeath extra casting distance w/ braid over lesser insert varieties (also inherently better durability w/ braids), and it is surprisingly sensitive.

    Something else you might consider… let Matt Straw talk you into the St. Croix AVS80MLM2 should you ever ply your efforts on an extremely clear fishery where distance-casting is crucial. Magical little rod.

    Sorry for the rant!

    I can’t wait to hear your further insights into how the color blue influences the midwest-finesse arena.

    - Josh

    • Ned Kehde

      Josh:
      Sorry that it has taken me a week to respond to your wonderful epistle about your finesse tactics.
      It my eyes it wasn't close to being a rant. In fact, we will post your insights on the Finesse News Network, too.
      Here's hoping that other anglers will employ your methods, and post their experiences.
      Please keep in touch.
      Ned

    • Ned Kehde

      Josh:
      A member of the Finesse News Network reported that he has searched in vain for the Okuma 7’ ML spinning rod, 2-piece, in their SST line-up that you recommended. Can you send a reply that indicates where he can find that rod?
      Thanks,
      Ned

    • Mike Fondren

      Josh

      You mention later the possibility of linking a picture of the Okuma rod you mentioned. What I would really like to see is a picture of the jig you described above. Very interesting. What line do you fish the jig on? Thanks for sharing.

      Mike

      • Josh

        I will assuredly do so here soon.

        As for line preference, I predominantly use 6 lb. Fireline w/ a fluoro tippet, or straight Sunline Shooter, 4 – 7 lb. test. It's largely a function of the scenario, but i'd say I generally prefer the Fireline setup.

        I have recently been experimenting w/ Nanosilk, straight or w/ a leader. Although situational, with cover a constraining variable, it has served to retain and further spur my interests.

        - Josh

  3. josh

    Dear Mr. Kehde, regarding your inquiry pertaining to the 7 ft., ML variant of the Okuma SST series, or rather the lack there of, I too ventured on-line to source one for those interested, but it seems to have fallen off Okuma’s relevant production roster… I can assure you that they exist, as I have several postured in the rack directly adjacent to me!

    Using the actual model number, it seems that you can still find them floating adrift various web-venues here and there. The # is SST-S-702ML.

    I am rather disheartened that it is no longer readily available. If anyone needs further help sourcing one, I can probably garner a few via my work.

    I was thinking of linking some pics, both of the rod and relevant presentation options that I enjoy, for all to see.

    Sorry for the late response, but the swim-bait bite has been too stellar…

    - Josh

    • Ned Kehde

      Josh:
      Thanks for taking the time to answer the question about the Okuma rod that a member of the Finesse News Network was hoping to acquire.
      We will forward your answer to him.
      Ned

    • Ned Kehde

      Josh:
      Can you contact Eldon at ejs_ks@netzero.net?
      He is seeking more information about the Okuma rods.
      Thanks,
      Ned

  4. Dan Fisher

    The St Croix Avid AVS70ULM2 is also a killer for tossing small, seductive baits a long distance. It's a 7' ultra-light that has a fast action that will drive small, open hooks into a fish with very little effort. The model I have is a 2-piece, but it's also available in a one piecer.
    I originally bought this rod to fish bluegills in farm ponds, but after swimming three inch grubs on exposed hook jig heads in Michigan, I decided that it was a very effective tool for bass extraction. Light enough to fish for extended periods without discomfort, it is a fun little rod to throw and to fight fish with.
    My two cents worth.
    Good fishing,
    Daniel

  5. Daniel Fisher

    …and another good rod, though a bit unwieldy in some instances, is the Bass Pro MC86ULS-2. This is an 8-1/2 foot ultra light live bait rod designed, I believe, for fishing bait under bobbers for walleye. I've found that it makes a dandy rod for tossing tiny baits such as miniscule panfish jigs and hard baits such as tiny countdown Rapala minnow baits. I have also dead-sticked small rubber worms on this rod with good success, and it makes a dandy rod to fish live bait or small jigs for panfish and walleyes too.
    At 8.5 feet, it's a lot of rod, but it's light and easy to fish, it controls line well on long casts, and it's a blast to fight fish on.
    Thanks and good fishing,
    Dan