Iditarod Mushers Vs. Hardcore Ice Anglers: Who's Tougher?

Iditarod Mushers Vs. Hardcore Ice Anglers: Who's Tougher?

In honor of the endless winter of 2013-'14 and the hearty souls who venture forth for recreation in the harsh conditions, we set out to see who was tougher, Iditarod sled dog racers or world-class, diehard ice fishing fanatics.

Both are cut from the same salty cloth. They don't merely endure below-zero temps and bitter wind chills, they revel in the fierce challenges of the northern winter. Mushers race nearly 1,000 miles across the Alaskan wilderness from Anchorage to Nome. World-class ice anglers sally forth on frozen lakes and rivers across the North. Both endure Arctic blasts, sub-zero temps, bitter windchills, and must battle through deep snow and slush to reach their destinations. Whether you call it grit or blame it on a seasonal lack of sunlight, there's no denying that both camps embrace winter's wrath while more delicate souls hunker by the hearth.

To gauge which group has more gristle, we considered the following 10 criteria. We list the winner of each point at the end of each item, and the overall champion at the conclusion of our final challenge. So snuggle up somewhere warm with your laptop, tablet, or mobile device, and read on see whether stoic mushers or diehard anglers deserve the title of toughest winter sports enthusiast.

Be sure to tune in to The Sportsman Channel to watch the Iditarod Unleashed beginning March 25th at 7PM ET. View Schedule!

Bare Digits

Due to the flesh-freezing cold involved in their respective sports, neither anglers nor mushers routinely expose appreciable amounts of skin. This would put the frostbite factor at a tie, except for the fact fishermen frequently have to bare their fingers to land and unhook fish, tie knots, and make countless other minute adjustments to gear that just can't be accomplished wearing gloves. Worse, their frigid digits are often repeatedly dunked in icewater while landing and releasing fish. Anglers score a point.

Companionship-in-fisherman

While both mushing and fishing can be solitary pursuits, each sport also fosters a unique fraternity among its faithful. Mushers rub elbows and share stories with fellow sledders at rest areas along the trail, while anglers often gather in the cozy comfort of a quasi-permanent icehouse to launch joint assaults on the underwater world. This one's a tie.

Tech Support

Iditarod racers have dogs, sleds, and their own two legs to propel them to the finish line. All are reliable, but decidedly low-tech. Anglers, on the other hand, enjoy a never-ending evolution of Space Age accouterments, from underwater cameras and fish-finding sonars to GPS mapping worthy of a battleship. For their undying dedication to old-school deprivation, mushers win this one.

Heavy Haulers

Granted, mushers tote plenty of gear across the tundra. But let's face it, the dogs do the pulling. Hardwater warriors, meanwhile, are often forced to lug leaden augers, electronics, buckets, and other necessities by hand, sometimes through hip-deep snow and slush. Score one for the icemen.

Nasty Teeth

Granted, huskies have choppers. But they don't bite the hands that feed them. At least not more than once. Fish, however, will. Especially big, mean, nasty predators like northern pike, whose malevolent maws are filled with razor-sharp teeth ready to inflict serious payback on the paws of the icemen who forcibly plucked them from their watery homes. Advantage, anglers.

The View

Ice anglers enjoy some pretty breathtaking scenery on the North's frozen fishing grounds. As they battle their way along the Iditarod Trail, mushers do, too. But the scene from the runners is never without a bobbing string of canine posteriors. In other words, if you're not the lead dog, the view never really changes. Mushers get this one.

Water Hazards

The Iditarod Trail is, well, a trail. Keep your dogs between the ditches and you know what to expect. Anglers, meanwhile, are free-ranging explorers who carve their own passages over off-grid fisheries across the Ice Belt. Despite a fisherman's best safety precautions, water hazards such as springs, currents, and even schools of fish can create dangerously thin ice. Another point for the anglers.

Toasty Garb

A rising tide raises all boats. Likewise, improvements in winter attire benefit anglers and mushers alike. High-performance cold-weather garments ranging from moisture-wicking baselayers to incredibly heat-stingy outerwear help keep dog sledders and fish squeezers toasty despite the big chill. Call this a tie.

Woofing It

Ice anglers can escape the hubbub of daily life on the frozen icepack. Except for the occasional whine of a snowmobile or whir of a power auger somewhere in the distance, all is quiet on the hardwater front. Mushers, meanwhile, are accompanied by the nonstop yaps, yelps, and yips of their canine companions. Thanks to this unending sled dog serenade, mushers win this one.

Tread Lightly

There's no sidestepping the fact that a hard-charging team of 10 to 12 sled dogs the size of small ponies generates a fair amount of trail bombs. Such processed dog food is admirably biodegradable and environmentally green. But woe is the musher who doesn't watch his step. No cigar, here, anglers. Chalk up another point for husky fans. Not including the two categories where our competitors tied, this leaves our final tally at four points for diehard anglers and four for the mushers. Given the extreme conditions and challenges each group overcomes to enjoy their favorite winter pastimes, we think it's fitting that they share the crown of toughest winter sports enthusiasts.

Anyone interested in a dog sled ice fishing adventure? In-Fisherman staffers have done it--Check it out!

White Wilderness

Basswood Bob

Murphy's Border Country Adventures

White Wilderness

Ely Dog Sleding

Get Your Fish On.

Plan your next fishing and boating adventure here.

Recommended for You

Some of Canada's best pike waters are within driving distance. Pike & Muskie

Best Drive-To Pike Waters

Gord Pyzer

Some of Canada's best pike waters are within driving distance.

These secrets will put more and bigger bass in your boat! Bass

Topwater Lure Secrets for Bass

Jim Edlund - April 26, 2018

These secrets will put more and bigger bass in your boat!

Blackened fish ready to serve with a side of okra and cucumber-red onion salad. This recipe is a treat! Fish Recipes

Blackened Fish Recipe

Tommy Thompson

Blackened fish ready to serve with a side of okra and cucumber-red onion salad. This recipe is...

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Giant Walleyes According To Calendar Periods

Giant Walleyes According To Calendar Periods

The search for big walleyes begins with an understanding of their nature, keying on prime locations during specific times of the year.

What

What's New from Cummings Nets?

There's more than meets the eye with new Cummings Nets Red Line. Find out what. With Mike Powell of Cummings and Game & Fish Editorial Director Adam Heggenstaller at ICAST 2019 in Orlando.

New Abu Garcia Baitcasting Reels

New Abu Garcia Baitcasting Reels

In the booth of one of fishing's all-time great reel makers, Outdoor Sportsman Group writer Lynn Burkhead and Andrew Wheeler of Pure Fishing discuss one of the brand new baitcasting reels from Abu Garcia being released at ICAST 2019.

See more Popular Videos

Trending Stories


Spring is prime time for pike. The Prespawn and Postspawn periods offer excellent odds at catching Pike & Muskie

How To Catch Pike In Spring

Dan Johnson - April 26, 2016

Spring is prime time for pike. The Prespawn and Postspawn periods offer excellent odds at...

Several methods are available to estimate the weight of a fish. Some use length as well as girth Biology

Walleye Length To Weight Conversion Chart

Dr. Rob Neumann - January 03, 2017

Several methods are available to estimate the weight of a fish. Some use length as well as...

Pole lines illustrate the paradox of catfishing. At a time when excellent rods, reels, and other Catfish

Catfish Pole Rigs

Richard Peterson with In-Fisherman - April 28, 2016

Pole lines illustrate the paradox of catfishing. At a time when excellent rods, reels, and...

See More Stories

More Ice Fishing

Targeting the largest predators puts tackle and tactics to their ultimate test. Ice Fishing

Custom Setups for the Toughest Predators

Steve Ryan - January 16, 2019

Targeting the largest predators puts tackle and tactics to their ultimate test.

Locating deep perch in the north country. Ice Fishing

Ice Fishing Deep Perch

Dan Johnson - January 01, 2015

Locating deep perch in the north country.

Sometimes, the best little ice jigs are found off the beaten path. Ice Fishing

Panfish Jigs Under the Radar

Cory Schmidt - February 03, 2017

Sometimes, the best little ice jigs are found off the beaten path.

See More Ice Fishing

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Temporary Price Reduction

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

×