Testing Hook Penetration

July 10, 2012 By In-Fisherman

Comparative Tests -- Recently, Sport Fishing magazine published tests comparing the penetrating ability of 12/0 closed-gap and open-gap J-style hooks with cutting-edge (triangular points) and cone-shaped points. Under identical conditions, closed-gap hooks, with the point bent slightly in toward the eye, penetrated deeper and more easily than did cutting-edge hooks with the points parallel to the hook shank. Cone-shaped points also resisted blunting and tissue tearing slightly more than cutting-edge points.

Freshwater literature contains few tests comparing the penetrating ability of various hooks. Based on this research, however, we might expect J-hooks with cone-shaped points to hook fish more easily than similarly sized and shaped J-hooks of equal quality that have cutting-edge points. There have yet been no such tests on smaller hooks, nor comparative tests including circle hooks, wide-gap hooks, and treble hooks.

Recent Videos

Learn

Celebrating 50 years with the March/April Edition of In-Fisherman Magazine

Learn

Celebrating 50 years with the March/April Edition of In-Fisherman Magazine

The editors at In-Fisherman including Doug Stange, Rob Neumann, Jim Nagy and Thomas Allen sit down and go through what many have concluded as the best issue of In-Fisherman magazine. The March/April 2025 edition is the official 50th Anniversary issue and all the contributing writes and editorial staff worked collectively for months to look back at 50 years of the fishing industry. The team is proud of this issue, and we think you will be too.

Learn

The Greatest Fishing Story Ever Told, Part 4 – Al Lindner: In-Fisherman Inception

Learn

The Greatest Fishing Story Ever Told, Part 4 – Al Lindner: In-Fisherman Inception

Al Lindner sits down for a second interview with In-Fisherman Storyline host Thomas Allen to discuss the early days of In-Fisherman magazine and how both Ron and Al got the organization off the ground. Al looks back at those days with pride, shares some stories that brought the brand to the forefront of the fishing industry and talks about his decision to eventually sell the title to an investment group. It's an intriguing discussion from the get-go.

Fishing

The Greatest Fishing Story Ever Told, Part 3 – Doug Stange: The Iowa Days

Fishing

The Greatest Fishing Story Ever Told, Part 3 – Doug Stange: The Iowa Days

In-Fisherman Editor-in-Chief Doug Stange sits down with Thomas Allen to relive the early days of his youth in Iowa. He talks about how his fishing passion was born, why catfish are so important to American anglers and the duo discusses the legend of Otis “Toad” Smith and his impact on Doug's storytelling. Mr. Stange has contributed so much to the In-Fisherman platform over the years, and hearing him tell stories of the old day is an absolute privilege.

Fishing

In-Fisherman Storyline: The Ross Robertson Story

Fishing

In-Fisherman Storyline: The Ross Robertson Story

Longtime In-Fisherman contributor and renowned Lake Erie walleye guide Ross Robertson connected with Thomas Allen to talk about how he kicked his career off and, of course, they got off on a few rabbit trails along the way. This is a fun discussion about what it takes to be a professional in the industry, what to avoid and what you definitely need to do if this career path is of interest. Strap in and listen, this is a long one but entertaining from the word go!

Fishing

Ice Fishing Tips: Slow down and get stealthy when chasing big walleyes

Fishing

Ice Fishing Tips: Slow down and get stealthy when chasing big walleyes

Our good friend and longtime In-Fisherman contributor Ross Robertson shares a few tips that will help you stay stealthy and more successful when chasing walleyes through hard water. He talks about minimizing noise, keeping tackle handy and staying comfortable in the right shelter--regardless of the cold winter weather. These are excellent tips that will help you catch more fish through the ice.

Gear

A Clever Finesse Alternative to a Jighead Minnow Presentation

Gear

A Clever Finesse Alternative to a Jighead Minnow Presentation

Looking for another finesse option this spring when the fish aren't reacting to a jighead minnow presentation? Check out the HideUp Coike in the smaller 17 mm size. It's been working for Lake Biwa guide Haruki Takeda in Japan.

Gear

The Scoop on the New HideUp Coike Soft Plastic Bait

Gear

The Scoop on the New HideUp Coike Soft Plastic Bait

SPRO's Syd Rives recently visited Japan and met up with Lake Biwa guide Haruki Takeda to get the scoop on the new HideUp Coike soft plastic bait and the best ways to rig it.

Fishing

The Greatest Fishing Story Ever Told, Part 2 - Al Lindner: The Road to Hayward

Fishing

The Greatest Fishing Story Ever Told, Part 2 - Al Lindner: The Road to Hayward

This is the second part in an extended series we're producing to help celebrate 50 years of In-Fisherman. The legendary Al Lindner and his late brother Ron began In-Fisherman back in the 70s, with lots of twists and turns along the way.

Fishing

The Greatest Fishing Story Ever Told, Part 1 - Mark Zona

Fishing

The Greatest Fishing Story Ever Told, Part 1 - Mark Zona

In lieu of In-Fisherman celebrating 50 amazing years serving anglers across North America as the authority on multi-species freshwater angling, Storyline host Thomas Allen sits down with his friend Mark Zona—host of Zona's Awesome Fishing Show. The goal is to kick off a lengthy series called The Greatest Fishing Story Ever Told. During his early years, Mark was influenced by the In-Fisherman staff to learn how to fish, and then to teach fishing. A remarkable career exemplifies how much fishing means to this man, and no one better than Mark Zona to begin an exciting series to include guests like Doug Stange, Al Lindner, James Lindner, Gary Roach and all the cast of characters that were instrumental to getting In-Fisherman off the ground to where it is today. This is part 1.

Destinations

IF In-Fisherman Storyline: The World's LARGEST Ice Fishing Tournament

Destinations

IF In-Fisherman Storyline: The World's LARGEST Ice Fishing Tournament

Held locally in Brainerd, Minnesota, this year is the 35th annual Brainerd Jaycees Ice Fishing Extravaganza on famed Gull Lake. Thousands of anglers from all over the state, country and world gather to compete for an impressive purse that pays out to 150 competitors. Curious how it works? Sheena Ziegler, Mike Kuck and Andrew Jay swing by the Storyline Studios to give the full inner workings to the largest ice fishing derby on the planet. You should come and give it a try, you'll love it! https://www.icefishing.org

Learn

In-Fisherman Storyline: Stormy Stories with the Fascinating Craig Storms

Learn

In-Fisherman Storyline: Stormy Stories with the Fascinating Craig Storms

Our good friend Craig Storms, or Stormy to those who know him best stopped by the In-Fisherman headquarters to sit down and share the details of his interesting career. Host Thomas Allen digs into Stormy's early days and finds a long list of similarities in how their careers began and changed directions. Craig works with Dakota Lithium and shares a tremendous amount of insight to the lithium battery market, and how anglers are better powered on the water than ever before. This is a good listen!

Learn

BEST Cold-Weather Fishing Gear Tips: Keep Your Hands, Feet AND Tackle From Freezing

Learn

BEST Cold-Weather Fishing Gear Tips: Keep Your Hands, Feet AND Tackle From Freezing

Our buddy Ross Robertson and head honcho at Bigwater Fishing talks about some of his top methods to keep his feet and hands from freezing, but also how to avoid frozen line. This is solid-gold advice.

See All Videos

Buy Digital Single Issues

Don't miss an issue.
Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Get the In-Fisherman App

Other Magazines

Game & Fish

In-Fisherman

Florida Sportsman

Fly Fisherman

See All Other Magazines

Special Interest Magazines

2023 Fly Fisherman Destinations

Buy A Copy

2023 Fly Fisherman Destinations

Buy A Copy

2023 Fly Fishing Made Easy

Buy A Copy

2023 Fly Fishing Made Easy

Buy A Copy

2023 Catfish In-Sider Guide

Buy A Copy

2023 Catfish In-Sider Guide

Buy A Copy

2023 In-Fisherman Bass Guide

Buy A Copy

2023 In-Fisherman Bass Guide

Buy A Copy

2023 Kayak Fishing Fun

Buy A Copy

2023 Kayak Fishing Fun

Buy A Copy

2023 In-Fisherman Bass Guide Gear Box

Buy A Copy

2023 In-Fisherman Bass Guide Gear Box

Buy A Copy

See All Special Interest Magazines

More You May Be Interested In

Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All In-Fisherman subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?

Subscribe Now

In-Fisherman Storyline Podcast

Subscribe & Save.

Testing Hook Penetration

Video That May Interest You

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

Recent Videos

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Buy Digital Single Issues

Don't miss an issue.Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Other Magazines

Game & Fish

Game & Fish

In-Fisherman

In-Fisherman

Florida Sportsman

Florida Sportsman

Fly Fisherman

Fly Fisherman

Special Interest Magazines

2023 Fly Fisherman Destinations

2023 Fly Fisherman Destinations

2023 Fly Fishing Made Easy

2023 Fly Fishing Made Easy

2023 Catfish In-Sider Guide

2023 Catfish In-Sider Guide

2023 In-Fisherman Bass Guide

2023 In-Fisherman Bass Guide

2023 Kayak Fishing Fun

2023 Kayak Fishing Fun

2023 In-Fisherman Bass Guide Gear Box

2023 In-Fisherman Bass Guide Gear Box

More You May Be Interested In

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Get Digital Access.

Not a Subscriber?

Get a Full Yearof Guns & Ammo& Digital Access.

Get the Newsletter

Don't miss an issue.
Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Get a Full Year
of Guns & Ammo
& Digital Access.