Baits For Shorecasting Walleyes
July 09, 2012
In the end, success is a matter of where you fish and what lures you choose to make the fish bite. The best all-around lure ever for shorecasting walleyes, in the situations I faced in natural lakes years ago, was the old #13 Husky Rapala, doctored with lead shot so it fished perfectly for the situation at hand. I really don't miss tinkering with a drill and adding lead shot to make the baits cast farther and to fish at just the right depth -- that is, until I meet a situation in which no other bait fishes at just the right depth. My second choice for a doctored bait was the 5-inch Bagley Bang-O Lure, which is still available.
Today, you can do serious big-fish duty with one of the Smithwick Rogues, a #12 or #14 Rapala Husky Jerk, or a #12 Rapala Long Cast Minnow. These are big baits that have serious wobbling action for attracting and triggering big fish after dark.
The Floating Super Rogue (5 inches, 3/8 ounce) is a great bait for very shallow fishing in, say, less than two feet of water (or when you have little distance between weeds and surface). It casts farther than the other floaters I'm familiar with, except perhaps the Cotton Cordell Redfin, another good bait. I prefer the action of the Rogue for walleyes, though.
The Suspending Super Rogue (5 inches, 1/2 ounce) casts better than some of the other suspenders on the market, because it weighs slightly more. It also swims a bit deeper -- into the 3-foot range, on a retrieve. The Suspending Rattlin' Rogue, meanwhile, is a 5.5-inch bait that runs about the same depth. All the Rogues can be made to run shallower by slowing the retrieve and holding your rod tip high.
I've spent most of my time in recent years fishing with Husky Jerks and, as of last year, the Long Cast Minnow, baits that are very effective at night. The #12 Husky Jerk measures 4.75 inches and weighs 1/3 ounce. The #14 is 5.5 inches and 1/2 ounce. Because of the way they're constructed, they both fish at about the same depth (from 1.5 to 4 feet). Meanwhile, the #12 Long Cast Minnow measures 4.75 inches, weighs 11/16 ounce and works in depths of about 1.5 to 4 feet. This one really is the longest-casting lure out there, all other things being equal.
The knock by some anglers about the Long Cast Minnow is that it doesn't measure up actionwise for fishing at night. With a little tinkering that can be changed, and also, the lure fishes a little shallower. So, too, can you increase the wobbling action of the Husky Jerks, also making them fish a little shallower. Wider-wobbling baits give off more flash and vibration and often get more action at night. Just take a pliers, pinch the hookeye a little flatter and then bend it down slightly. Remove the split ring on these lures and use a Cross-Lok or Coast Lock snap to connect main line to lure.
Continued -- click on page link below.
The Rapalas can actually be two baits in one, displaying their outstanding natural action right out of the box. With a bit of hookeye tinkering, they can also display a wider, more "injured" wobble. I'm no expert at pier action on the Great Lakes, but I think I'd catch on pretty fast, and it seems to me a nose-tinkered Long Cast Minnow should be a real killer on the piers after dark.
Beginning anglers are frequently obsessed with baits that are, in fact, too small. They also are in a constant tizzy about finding some secret herky-jerky way to work those baits. The old boys cast them out and reel them in -- slow and steady. No jerking. If you must use pauses in a retrieve, fine, but my reasonably-educated guess is that it will cost you fish over the course of decades.The percentage is with slow and steady. Walleyes feel it, see it, track it, eat it. There's more chance to feel and see a bigger bait at night. When they attack a bigger bait, there's more bait there for them to hit it -- less chance for error.
Thumper Plastics -- The other class of baits that shines for big fish is shad-bodied thumper baits fished on a leadhead jig. In the old days, the 4-inch Mister Twister Sassy Shad was the only thumper available, and it usually had to be fished on a wedgehead jig with a hook too short to match well with the 4-inch plastic.
If you're after bigger fish, don't be tempted to fish with three-inch plastics. Four inches is the minimum after dark. The best shad body I've used recently is Berkley's Inshore Power Swim Shad, which measures 5 inches. The 4-inch Berkley Inshore Power Pogy is another good option. Lots of companies make 4-inch shads. YUM offers the G-Shad, for example, which also is available in a 6-inch model. I haven't done enough fishing after dark with 6-inch baits to comment. My guess is that 6-inch baits are fine, but 7 inches is getting too large for most situations.
The best jigheads I've found for larger plastics are from Matzuo, either the Darter Jig or the Flat Jig -- especially the Flat Jig, which has a beautiful long "sickle" hook that's perfect for longer plastics. The most versatile size is 1/4 ounce, which has a 3/0 hook. The same size Darter Jig (1/4-ounce) works well, but by design tends to fish just a little deeper. I like the Darter Jig because it isn't painted. The natural color of lead has always been the best overall color, in my book. When I fish the Flat Jig after dark, I usually use a white head.