June 03, 2014
By Jeff Kutcha
In the southwest corner of Michigan sits a small but significant north-country stream. The St. Joseph River, a turbid Lake Michigan tributary that winds through large portions of the Mitten State and Indiana, draws strong runs of popular Great Lakes gamefish, like walleyes and steelhead. These seasonal migrations attract the attention of serious anglers from across the Midwest. In turn, fishery personnel react accordingly by using science and good judgment to achieve sustainable fish populations.
What is less well-known is that the St. Joe plays home to a healthy northern population of flathead catfish, a fish gaining in popularity with fishermen. Because of increasing pressure on these fish, managers are interested in learning more about St. Joe's flatheads to form smart management strategies.
Dr. Trent Sutton, associate professor of fisheries biology at Purdue University, and graduate student Dan Daugherty, conducted research projects in 2002 and 2003 that explored the St. Joe's flathead catfish movements and habitat. They used ultrasonic telemetry to determine habitat use and movement, and recorded over 640 observations. Transmitters were implanted into 39 flatheads between 17 and 44.5 inches (2.9 to 39.6 pounds).
"What makes our work unique from other Midwestern studies is that we're the first to have done anything on flathead populations in the Great Lakes watershed," says Sutton. "The St. Joe flatheads are quite unique in that they are far out of their core range. If you look at a map of geographic distribution, this group is isolated all by itself in the northeast portion of the normal range. These Michigan fish stand out like a little patch on the map, whereas everything else is connected."
The St. Joe is a smart target for study because it contains a healthy population of flathead catfish that see relatively low exploitation rates. And though these northern fish might grow as fast or get as large as their southern counterparts, the study remains important because other Great Lakes tributaries hold similar flathead populations that could benefit from the research.
In addition to the St. Joseph River, Michigan has flatheads in the Muskegon and Kalamazoo rivers, among others, and there are a handful of major Great Lakes tributaries in Wisconsin, like the Fox and Wolf rivers, that hold them, too. All these waters have viable populations that deserve sound management, and the only way to improve it is to have a good understanding of the dynamics of one flathead population that adequately represents others within the region.
Anglers benefit from this research, too. Findings from fishery science eventually arrive on anglers' laps in the form of trade publications and cutting-edge angling media, like In€‘Fisherman. With regard to Sutton and Daugherty's work on northern flathead catfish, research brings to light key information that eliminates much of the work in the game of flathead catfishing.
Habitat Through the Seasons
Understanding habitat requirements is crucial to completing any fishing puzzle. Interestingly, Sutton and Daugherty discovered that the preferred cover of flatheads changed by season. "Complex wood structures in the form of logjams comprise the most often used form of cover for adult flathead catfish throughout the warm water seasons," says Sutton. "Nearly three-quarters of the observations found flatheads in sizeable logjams. Smaller fish tended to use riprap structures made from large, angular chunks of concrete. Obviously, the smaller fish would have smaller hiding requirements, so this works fine for young fish."
Flatheads choose these areas because of the quality of the cover and hunting opportunities. Logjams tend to have larger openings that allow better movement and hiding opportunities for larger fish. Riprap, on the other hand, is much more uniform and typically holds smaller spaces that protect juveniles from large predators.
Gravel-bottomed areas played a negligible role in spring, summer and fall. And the presence of deep water was a minor factor for determining flathead catfish location during the bulk of the open water season. In fact, Sutton's research showed that St. Joe cats have a distinct preference for water shallower than 9 feet for use as a home base in spring, summer, and fall.
Everything changed, though, when flatheads made a major move from summer hunting grounds to wintering holes. Pools with rocky bottoms and deeper than 12 feet attracted flatheads when winter arrived, likely a result of reduced current in the greater depths. Flatheads held in these pools throughout the winter months, barely moving until spring.
Seasonal Flathead Catfish Movements
The Purdue researchers also found that St. Joe flatheads showed trends in seasonal movement. With the onset of spring's warming temperatures, fish began leaving winter hibernating holes for familiar warm-water hangouts.
"Once water temperatures reached about 50ºF, flathead catfish began moving around," says Sutton. "Fifty degrees is a kind of magical number for many fish species, and it works well for the flathead catfish, too. But what's more interesting is that flatheads coming out of winter dormancy, in many instances, move back to the very structures they used the previous year. In our studies, most of the tagged fish returned from wintering areas to their original capture locations from the previous summer over a two-week period. In fishery research terms, this behavior is referred to as high site fidelity."
Distances covered by St. Joe's flatheads in spring were the greatest of the year, averaging over 1,500 yards. In May and June, these fish moved back and forth from riprap to log structures on a regular basis. Some of this movement is attributable to migrations from wintering areas to summer homes, and some occurred as a result of spawning rituals, as both rocky and woody features are frequently used by flatheads for spawning zones.
During the heat of summer, the tendency for long-distance movement slowed. Most of the time, when flathead catfish reached hot-weather haunts they stayed close to home, foraging extensively on nighttime forays in the immediate area of their base. At this time, the majority of fish moved less than 3/8 of a mile from the original capture site.
Fall observations once again showed much movement of flathead catfish as they transitioned from summer to winter sites. Flatheads stayed in summer areas until water temperatures dropped to about 50ºF, at which point they moved an average of over 1,200 yards, with industrious specimens moving up to nearly 4,000 yards. Once they reached where they wanted to spend the winter, they remained inactive until the following spring.
"These fish become absolutely dormant at that time," says Sutton. "Scuba divers have found flatheads in deep wintering areas, all lined up in single-file on the bottom, each fish acting as a sort of current break for the next. They're covered with mud or silt and not moving at all."
Sutton believes that what pushes flatheads toward deep water is temperature, more so than photoperiod (the change in daylight hours in a twenty-four hour period). Specifically, he points to the magical 50°F mark, which is so important in triggering migration tendencies in other gamefish, like walleyes, to be the catalyst that drives them to make location changes in both spring and fall.
Interestingly, the movement of flathead catfish was non-directional during all seasons. This is somewhat different from the way anglers understand more popular migrations of river fish. Walleyes and steelhead, for example, show distinct upstream migration trends prior to the spawn and downstream migration tendencies during postspawn. But not St. Joe's flatheads. When there was a distinct seasonal movement underway, some fish went upstream and some went downstream; there was no clear trend in direction.
Daily Flathead Catfish Movements
Daugherty tracked the daily movements of St. Joe flatheads for two months in the summer of 2003. He observed that flatheads showed a distinct preference for moving out of cover to stretch their fins, particularly at night. And though the overall movement on these forays was often considerable, the fish usually stayed close to home.
"Most people think of catfish as wait-and-watch predators, but flatheads actually move around and actively hunt for food," says Sutton. "It's probably easier for them to do this in more open areas outside their woody daytime cover. Flathead catfish have eyes that are located on top of their head and a lower jaw that undercuts, which shows that these fish are clearly approaching their prey from below. So they're cruising low in the water column, looking up for something that looks good to eat."
Throughout the nighttime feeding period, flatheads chose mild, main-river currents for their hunting grounds and stayed out of backwater areas. The trend was to move out from cover toward relatively shallow (less than 10 feet) open areas to feed. By dawn, the St. Joe flatheads were neatly tucked in loggy structures and, most times, in the very ones they left the night before. During daylight hours, they remained in logjams and other woody debris and showed little movement.
Flathead Science: Angling Tips for Small Northern Rivers
Science has helped us make better decisions on how and where to spend our fishing time. In recent years, traditional thoughts on the areas fish call home have been called into question. With regard to flathead catfish, it seems that deep water isn't always their home, especially during summer. Purdue researchers Trent Sutton and Dan Daugherty found that summer flatheads occupied the shallowest water of the year in anywhere from 3 to 9 feet. So, for warmwater anglers bent on maximizing fishing time, fish shallow in small to medium northern rivers. Research suggests that riverbend pools can be low-percentage water in the dog days.
It's equally valuable to know that flatheads are intimately familiar with the lay of their neighborhoods. Big cats spend their feeding hours roaming well-known areas close to home, which in most cases comprise large, complex logjams. When prospecting new water for big fish, stay within about 75 yards of any sizeable woody structure. Live baitfish (sunfish, suckers, or shad) in the 6- to 8-inch range anchored in place a foot or two off bottom is a dependable option for summer flatheads.
For eater-sized specimens, check structures having smaller crevices and hiding areas like riprap or rock and wood combinations that allow juveniles to escape adult predators. Downsize the offering; 3- to 5-inch minnows are good finger-food for 18-inch and smaller flatheads. Just remember to stay close to the rocks when presenting baits.
Feeding occurs most when the sun goes down — therefore, the bulk of angling effort for flatheads should take place during the night. During daylight hours, Daugherty's flatheads showed a distinct preference for inactivity. For anglers who shun the night, however, floating a big livebait near woody cover might get a flathead's attention, especially during the warmest days of the summer.
Whereas cold-water channel cats are rising in popularity with die-hard whisker chasers, flathead anglers would probably do better to sharpen hooks and pour lead. Daugherty found that flatheads didn't move when water temperatures dipped below 50°F. By that time, St. Joe cats had found their wintering homes at the bottoms of deep holes and scour pools. While cold-water flatheads can be caught, they're often congregated and vulnerable to snagging, both intentional and unintentional. If cold water is your game, tread lightly on this precious resource.
All-Tackle World Record - Ken Paulie
If Ken Paulie's gargantuan world-record flathead doesn't make your heart skip a beat, you best check your pulse. At 123 pounds even, it tops the National Fresh Water Fishing Hall of Fame's all-tackle and 14-pound line class standings, and photos of the behemoth will make you think twice about dabbling your toes off the dock.
Taken from Elk City Reservoir, Kansas, on May 14, 1998, the fish stretched the tape a whopping 61 inches and sported a pleasantly plump, 42¾-inch girth. Paulie was crappie fishing at the time, and hooked it on a jig-and-minnow. Like many world records, it was not without controversy. It was verified while alive by Kansas Department of Wildlife and Parks fishery biologist Sean Lynott. But details of the catch — such as the relatively light tackle Paulie was using, and his statement that it didn't put up much of a fight — raised eyebrows in the cat community. Still, the record stands to this day as a testament to the immense proportions flatheads are capable of attaining.
Georgia - Carl Sawyer
The Peachtree flathead record rests in a tie, and it's a whopper. Eighty-three pounds is the mark to beat, thanks to Carl Sawyer and Jim Dieveney. Sawyer struck first, pulling his 83-pounder from the Altamaha River near Jesup on June 22, 2006. In doing so, he literally destroyed the old record of 67 pounds, 8 ounces. Sawyer was fishing a 'hand-sized ' bluegill on a 7/0 circle hook with 50-pound mainline and a 3-ounce sinker, in a 15- to 17-foot deep hole. He reported that the 54-inch giant offered a 15- to 20-minute battle before surrendering boatside.
Georgia - Jim Dieveney
Carl Sawyer retained solo claim to the record until Dieveney hooked a nearly identical leviathan July 11, 2010, while fishing the Altamaha in Wayne County. Fishing alone but wielding a rod fit for sharks, he managed to land his 52½-inch prize all by himself. Interestingly, a mammoth 103-pound flathead was taken on trotline on the Ocmulgee River in August of 2009, leaving little doubt a tiebreaker resides somewhere in Georgia's cat-rich waterways.
Iowa - Joe Baze
'Catfish ' Joe Baze of Chariton, Iowa, set the Hawkeye flathead record in June 1958 with this 81-pound behemoth, taken from Lucas County's Lake Ellis. Baze was a consummate fisherman, with numerous trophy catches to his credit. As the story goes, he loved devoting Saturdays to fishing a nearby lake, but almost stayed home the day of his big catch due to a foul east wind. When the wind switched late in the day, however, he and his son geared up, headed for Ellis — and made history.
Michigan - Dale Blakely
Michigan's state record might not rank among the top 10 fattest flatheads of all time. But it's the newest record-holder we ran across — taken on January 12, 2014 — and has an interesting story to boot. For starters, the 52-pound fish was caught through the ice on Cass County's Barron Lake. Dale Blakely was enjoying his second-ever hardwater adventure, fishing a jig and waxworm for crappies. He hadn't had a bite all day when, at 3 p.m., the giant cat inhaled his jig. The catch trumped the existing record of 49.8 pounds, and was quickly verified by the state DNR. Officials noted that flatheads do not naturally occur in the lake, and speculated that the fish may have arrived with the illicit assistance of a 'bucket biologist ' at some point in its life. Regardless of its origins, Blakely's record stands. 'Catching this fish was the most exhilarating experience, ' he said.
Oklahoma - Richard Williams
Richard Williams was fishing for bass in El Reno City Reservoir on May 11, 2010 when he hooked into a monstrous fish far bigger than anything he'd expected to hit his Strike King crankbait. After a pitched battle, he reeled in a 51-inch-long, Sooner state record flathead weighing in at 78 pounds, 8 ounces. Williams' big cat topped the old record of 76 pounds, set on the Poteau River near Wister. Though admittedly not a cat fancier, Williams told the press at the time that he considered his record catch 'pretty cool. ' Indeed. And so do we. Although truth be told, we'd rather hook up with the 60-inch, 106-pound thug C. Clubb caught on a trotline in Wister Lake in 1977. That remarkable giant holds the Oklahoma record for 'unrestricted ' tackle.
Texas - James Laster
At 98 pounds, 8 ounces, James Laster's Lone Star lunker was big enough to topple the previous Texas benchmark, but not the all-tackle world record. It did, however, capture the Fresh Water Fishing Hall of Fame's 16-pound line-class record. Laster pulled the mighty flathead from Lake Palestine on December 2, 1998 while bank-fishing for crappies. It measured 53 inches long, with a 40-inch girth. The previous Texas record, 98 pounds even, had stood for 22 years. The new record flathead — named Taylor after Laster's grandson — was transported to the Texas Freshwater Fisheries Center in Athens for display, but was released back into Palestine two years later after it stopped eating.